Skip to content

The Line Where a Full Freezer Gets Greedy

The Backstrap Stack Three deer in twenty eight hours. That was me, one November a few years back, standing in a snow covered food plot behind the house and looking at a pile of…

The Backstrap Stack

Three deer in twenty eight hours. That was me, one November a few years back, standing in a snow covered food plot behind the house and looking at a pile of meat that would not fit in the freezers I actually owned. Somewhere on the internet a guy had posted the same number, three in twenty eight hours, with a caption about how blessed he felt. I read it and felt a little knot in my stomach that I could not name, because on paper I was having the best season of my life and the sticker on the wall said I was supposed to feel nothing but grateful. The knot was the part of me that knew I had stopped hunting and started collecting. I just did not want to admit that yet, because admitting it meant the freezer had stopped being a reason and become an alibi.

Editorial image for The Backstrap Stack in The Line Where a Full Freezer Gets Greedy

The Freezer Is a Scoreboard Now

Nobody tells you that a full freezer can lie to you. It sits there heavy and cold and full of proof, and you let it argue on your behalf every time a little voice asks what exactly you are doing out here. I used to hunt to put meat on the table. Then somewhere along the way the table got full, and full again, and full a third time, and still I was out there at first light because the season was open and a tag is a tag and you do not leave a tag in your pocket like some kind of quitter. The freezer became a scoreboard, and I was keeping score, and the deer were just the points. I told myself I was feeding the family. The family was three people and we could not eat three deer in a year, let alone in a long weekend. So a lot of it went to jerky, and some to the neighbor, and a few packages got freezer burn before we ever got to them, and I looked at that brown crinkled venison one morning and understood for the first time what the word waste actually means. It does not always mean tossing a carcass. It means killing something and then not treating the getting of it as a sacred, expensive thing.

Editorial image for The Freezer Is a Scoreboard Now in The Line Where a Full Freezer Gets Greedy

Greed Wears a Blaze Jacket

The embarrassing part is that I always thought greed in the woods looked like a poacher, some shadowy guy with a spotlight and no license shooting a deer out of season from a county road. Greed never looked like me in my blaze orange, legal tag, legal county, legal everything. But that is the trick of it. Greed rarely shows up holding something obviously illegal. It shows up holding one more permit, one more weekend, one more reason to stay out past when you need to. It wears the same clothes a good hunter wears, so for a long time I could not tell the difference between me and a guy doing it right, because on paper we were identical. The difference lived in the answer to one boring question, the one a stranger posted on the internet that same week: where do you draw the line for food? I read it and scrolled past fast, because I did not want to answer it. A man who has to scroll fast past a question is a man who already knows the answer and hates what it says.

Editorial image for Greed Wears a Blaze Jacket in The Line Where a Full Freezer Gets Greedy

Three In Twenty Eight Hours

There is a version of the story where three deer in twenty eight hours is the point. The years of empty stands, the waders, the blown stalks, the gas money, the alarm clocks, all of it paying off in one frozen weekend. I felt that version for about a day. Then I stood over the third deer and felt nothing much, and nothing much is a terrible thing to feel standing over an animal that gave you everything, because it means you have turned the whole thing into a transaction and the animal into inventory. I shot the third one because I could, because the tag was there, because the morning was clear, because nobody was going to stop me. Those are the exact reasons a man gives when he has stopped having a reason. A real reason sounds like something the freezer can actually hold, like a need, a hunger, a number your family can honestly eat. A fake reason sounds like opportunity, and opportunity is a bottomless pit, and you can pour deer into it forever and never fill it because it was never a container, it was a hole shaped like your own pride.

What the Land Gives Is Still a Budget

Deer are not an infinite number. That sounds so obvious it should not need saying, and yet the whole machinery of a modern season runs on acting like they are. I grew up hearing people talk about the herd like a bank account you never check, like the woods just mint more every spring whether you take one or eleven. Somebody put limits on us for a reason, and the reason was never to protect the deer from the wolves or the weather. It was to protect the deer from the people who feel like one more is always fine because one more is never the thing that collapses a herd. But it is never one more in isolation. It is a hundred thousand men each taking one more, each sure his one is nothing, each with a freezer holding the proof of how nothing it is. The land gives what it gives, and what it gives is still a budget, and a budget only works if you decide, before the season starts, what enough looks like.

Enough Has a Number

The fix turned out to be boring, which means it was hard. I had to sit down with a pencil and decide what enough actually was. Not what I could take, not what the tags allowed, not what my pride thought it deserved after twenty years of showing up. What my table needed. That number turned out to be a lot smaller than the number I had been taking, and staring at a small number next to a big ego is a quietly embarrassing way to spend an evening. But once I wrote it down, the season changed. I still went out, still sat the stands, still loved every cold, still morning of it. I just did not pull the trigger on everything that walked under me. I passed on a nice buck because the freezer was already set and the land owed me nothing further and a tag is not a summons. Passing felt awful for about ten seconds and then it felt like the whole point, like I had finally learned the one thing the animal had been trying to teach me the whole time, which is that restraint is not the opposite of a good season. Restraint is the thing that keeps tomorrow’s season from being someone else’s empty freezer.

The Line Is Where You Stop

Three in twenty eight hours, and the thing I remember now is not the rack or the shot or the snow. It is the feeling of nothing much, and the alarm it eventually turned into. The line for food is not a law and not a number on a tag count. It is a private line, drawn somewhere between what the season allows and what your table actually needs, and nobody will ever check it for you, and nobody will ever thank you for holding it. That last part is the part that matters. The woods do not clap when you pass. There is no scoreboard for the deer you let walk, no photo, no caption, no blessed. There is just the quiet knowledge, held by nobody but you and the land, that you took enough and stopped. I wish somebody had sat me down early and told me that a full freezer is not the trophy, it is the question, and the answer to that question is the only real tag that ever mattered. I would have still made the same mistakes, probably, because that is what I do. But I would have known what to call them sooner, and there is some value in naming a thing faster, even if you name it only in the dark of a snow covered food plot, standing over a pile you already know is bigger than you.