Skip to content

The Buck That Lived in a Number

The Buck That Lived in a Number For six straight Novembers, the same buck pulled the same trick on me. He would cross the creek bottom about twenty minutes after legal light, take a…

The Buck That Lived in a Number

For six straight Novembers, the same buck pulled the same trick on me. He would cross the creek bottom about twenty minutes after legal light, take a single slow look at the stand where I sat shivering, and then melt back into the cedar line like he had somewhere better to be. I measured his rack once through a borrowed spotting scope and wrote the number down in my phone because nobody carries a tape into a bow stand. One hundred and sixty-two inches, I told myself, and then I told my brother, and then I told a couple of guys at the gas station who did not ask. The number got rounder every time I said it. By season three it was one sixty-five. By season four I was saying one seventy and starting to believe the buck owed me something for all the mornings I had watched him walk off.

The freezer never got full in those years, and I want to be honest about why. It was not because the hunting was slow. It was because I stopped shooting does. A doe was a warm body forty yards out, an easy shot, a full cooler, but she had no rack to add to the number, and somehow a buck tag felt like the only tag worth filling. I passed on more easy deer in five seasons than my grandfather killed in forty years, and I told myself it was patience. It was patience the way a gambler who keeps doubling down calls it patience. Every time the big one slipped the cedars I went home empty and hungry and certain the next morning would be the one he finally stood still.

Editorial image for The Buck That Lived in a Number in The Buck That Lived in a Number

The Phrase a Man Says to Sound Wise

Somewhere in there I learned the phrase. You know it. Can’t eat the antlers. It is the kind of thing an old hunter says while he watches a young man drool over a trail camera photo, and it means the obvious thing, that a rack will not put meat on a table. I heard it a dozen times before I ever said it myself, and I said it the way you say anything you have heard a hundred times, which is to say I said it without hearing it. I used it on other people. I used it to sound like a man who had his priorities straight while I drove home with an empty truck bed and a head full of antlers. I think that is the worst way to use wisdom, wearing it as a costume so nobody looks too close at what you are actually doing.

The truth is I had not eaten venison in five years. Not because I did not like it. Because there was never any in the freezer. My wife stopped asking what we were going to do for meat in the fall because she knew the answer, which was nothing, we were going to do nothing, I was going to spend every spare hour sitting in a tree waiting on a deer I had mentally reserved for myself. I had turned a food source into a lottery ticket and then gotten surprised when the lottery did not pay out. That is not hunting. That is feeding a hole in yourself with a picture of a buck.

Editorial image for The Phrase a Man Says to Sound Wise in The Buck That Lived in a Number

The Morning the Stand Chose for Me

It ended on a Tuesday, which tells you everything, because nothing I ever planned went the way I planned it. I was not even supposed to be out that morning. I had told myself I was done, that the season was a wash, and then I woke up before the alarm anyway and drove out to the property because going felt better than admitting the season had beaten me. I climbed the old ladder stand in the dark, the one I had not sat all season because the big buck never came that way, and I sat there with no plan, no number, no particular hope. Just a man with a bow and a legal tag and nothing to prove to anybody, which was the first honest state I had been in for six years.

The doe came in silent the way they do, materializing out of the gray scrub like she had been there the whole time. She was a big old girl, thick through the chest, the kind of deer that fills a freezer and then some. Broadside at thirty-five yards, feeding, unaware, giving me every second in the world to think about it. I did what I always did. I looked past her for antlers. I scanned the timber behind her for the big one following. That is how deep the habit had gone, that I could have a full stomach standing in front of me and I was squinting into the trees looking for a trophy that was not there.

And then I heard the phrase again, not from an old man this time, not from a YouTube video, just from the quiet part of myself that had been trying to get a word in for half a decade. Can’t eat the antlers. She was right there. The meat was right there. I drew, and I shot her the way a man shoots a deer he actually intends to eat.

Editorial image for The Morning the Stand Chose for Me in The Buck That Lived in a Number

What the Freezer Knows

She ran maybe forty yards and dropped. I climbed down and found her with my hands shaking a little, not from the shot but from the strangeness of finally doing the simple thing. I field dressed her in the cold and thought about how many years of hamburger, steaks, roasts, and sausage I had talked myself out of by waiting on a deer that had never once offered me anything but a view of his back. The antlers were still in the timber somewhere, still pushing their way through the brush, still worth exactly as much as they had always been worth, which is nothing you can put on a plate.

I butchered her myself that year, which I had also stopped doing, because it turns out when you never shoot a deer you never learn to cut one up, and when you never learn, you start believing only the processor can do it. That was another costume. Processing took me three evenings and a lot of swearing and one badly cut backstrap that I am too proud to describe, but when it was done the freezer was full for the first time in six years, and I stood in front of it with the door open and the cold air on my face like a man looking at a bank account that was finally not empty. There was no rack in there. There was no number. There was just food, row after row of it, and I understood all at once why the old man kept saying the same boring thing for forty years.

The Buck Is Still Out There

He is, by the way. I have seen him twice more, both times too far, both times moving through cover like he knows exactly what I cost myself waiting for him. I do not begrudge him. He was never the problem. The problem was a man who had confused a set of antlers with a reason to hunt, and a reason to hunt with a reason to never bring anything home. The phrase is so simple it almost sounds stupid when you say it right. You cannot eat antlers. You can only look at them, and looking is fine, it is part of the draw, but looking does not feed your kids and it does not justify six Novembers of an empty freezer.

This season I will shoot the first legal deer that gives me a clean shot, buck or doe, rack or no rack, because the freezer does not care about inches and neither, it turns out, does anything that actually matters. I will still look for the big one. I will still feel that little electric jolt if he steps out. But I will not pass on a full cooler to chase a number that only ever lived in my phone and the gaps between my ears. The antlers are nice to admire. The meat is what keeps you, and that is a lesson the old man never stopped trying to hand me, and one I finally stopped being too proud to take.